Cynthia P. Willow Books - Stories Spun in the Shade
Follow Cynthia >
  • Home
  • Filmer Little
  • BOXED SETS
  • Ciella Naden
  • AUDIO BOOKS
  • Contact
  • THE FAIRY COLLECTION
  • SHELLEY
  • Letsi and the Labyrinth
  • The Kingsley Adventures
  • The Hell Tales
  • The Karini & Lamek Chronicles
  • Saving Private Benjamin
  • Rhyming Picture Books for Children
  • Acknowledgements
  • About Kingsley Lake
  • Indie Authors / Writers
  • Ciella In The Woods Photo Shoot
  • Dragon Gloves
  • Crocheted Scarf
  • Coraline Doll
  • Basket
  • Earrings & Choker Set

"Are you a good witch or a bad witch?"

12/16/2012

6 Comments

 
Picture
Picture
And Dorothy replied, “I’m not a witch at all.  Witches are old and ugly.”

Giggles were heard all over as the munchkins knew that witches could indeed be beautiful and young like Dorothy.  And one munchkin in particular thought to himself, ‘She might not be a witch, but I bet she used The Force.”

What?  That’s not how you remember the story?  Well, I embellished a little, but only to explain my thoughts on magic, and anything that can be disguised as such, in books and movies. 

The Wizard of Oz is a movie that I watched every year with my dad.  Once a year, one of the major networks would air it.  I can’t remember if it was NBC, ABC, or CBS, but I know it was one of the three because those were about the only channels we had.  I know I’m showing my age.  This time with my dad is one of the few memories I have with him from childhood as my parents divorced when I was six.  I can’t even imagine what childhood would have been like without The Wizard of Oz.  This movie contained everything that makes childhood enjoyable:  Music, awesome characters not seen in everyday life, good vs. evil, and MAGIC!  I don’t have to explain it.  I’m sure you’ve seen it.  One thing I don’t remember is anyone in my church or any Christian I knew banning it from their house nor letting their children watch it.  My mom and dad certainly had no problem with it.  When I had children of my own, I bought it on VHS and we watched it together over and over.  My daughter was hooked on it right away and even had her own pair of ruby slippers.  I had passed down my love for fantasy to her. 

Not long after that, I heard of a new movie that critics were calling a modern-day Wizard of Oz.  What movie could possibly be compared to my most beloved movie of all-time?  Yes, you guessed it.  Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone.  At this time, I didn’t go see the movie in the theater.  I actually forgot about it.  But the more I went to church, the more buzz I heard about this movie and how demonic it was.  'No parent should let their child watch', etc.  I was young then and had a bad habit of following instead of leading.  I usually believed things without checking them out for myself too.  I was young and had a lot to learn.  Needless to say, I decided that Harry Potter would not come into my home.  And I even found it offensive that people had compared my beloved Wizard of Oz with this horrible movie. 

Looking back on this time, I don’t even understand what I thought was wrong with Harry Potter.  I just let other people tell me what I should and shouldn’t watch.  Now, without skipping ahead, those same people watch and love The Wizard of Oz and some other movies I won’t mention yet.  Stay tuned... 

Now, you’re wondering if I’ve watched Harry Potter?  Hmm… that’s an understatement, but how did it happen?  Well, sometimes things happen that are out of our control.  It just so happened that the year The Sorcerer’s Stone came out on VHS, we were at a family Christmas party.  Guess what movie one of our cousins had just bought and decided to play in her living room while we visited and had our get-together?  Yep!  Well, I tried to avoid it.  My kids were too busy playing to pay attention to the movie, so I wasn’t really worried about its influence on them, so I kept my mouth shut as far as requesting it not be played.  But I did everything I could to not watch it.  And so on the way home, an argument began between my husband and me because he had watched most of it and thought it was great.  I started repeating things that I’d only heard from other people; other people, who like myself, had not even watched the movie, I might add.  It was then that my husband was able to shoot down every argument I had, and pretty much made me sound like a stupid and ignorant hypocrite.  That’s pretty much what I was.  How was I going to bash something I knew little about, first of all?  And how was I to love and adore a movie with a good witch and a bad witch, yet hate Harry Potter?  And The Wizard of Oz wasn’t the only movie I owned and loved that fell into this category.  I also owned books with the same content.  Again, stay tuned 

The argument ended with us agreeing to disagree.  And then, my mother-n-law bought the VHS for my husband for Christmas.  So, there it was in my home.  And on the back of it, a quote:  “The Wizard of Oz of its time.  A complete triumph.” ~ Richard Roeper 

Well, over the next couple of days, Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone was played in our home, even though our kids were too small to like it or pay attention to it.  They played in their rooms mostly back then.  We had no cable because we couldn’t afford it, and I wasn’t as busy as I am now, so what did I wind up doing?  Yep!  I watched it.  I tried not to like it.  I really did.  But I fell in love with the movie and everything about it.  But it bothered me because I wasn’t sure if I should.  I talked to the Lord about it.  I prayed for a sign.  It came not long after in the form of a book in the Christian bookstore.  The book is called Wizards, Hobbits and Harry Potter: What Your Family Needs to Know [With CD], and it answered all my questions and even confirmed some thoughts I already had about the movie. 


I would list them all, but there are too many to list.  Instead I will tell you that I’ve watched all the movies and read all the books.  They are among my all-time favorites.  I no longer am offended that Harry Potter was compared to my beloved Wizard of Oz either.  I think it’s a good comparison seeing as how there are good witches and bad witches in Harry Potter. 

This is the time in the blog where I want to give the reasons I like Harry Potter other than for sheer entertainment.  The main reason is “integrity,” my favorite word.  My children are no longer too small to enjoy Harry Potter.  Over the years we’ve watched the movies every time they came out in the theater beginning with Chamber of Secrets, which happens to be my favorite.  I have tried my best to teach my kids good morals and ethics, one of which is integrity.  I have taught them the Bible and we try to watch movies and read books that enforce those same principles.  Harry Potter is bursting with integrity.  Most people, who probably haven’t watched them near as many times as we have, would say that Harry Potter glorifies the breaking of rules.  I would agree that it does at times, but the picture is way bigger than that.  So many books and movies have the main character seekt revenge for some horrible thing that happened to them.  Harry had a pretty bad life growing up as an orphan, much like the Cinderella story we all know.  And then, he makes an enemy of Malfoy, who would like him dead and came close to killing him more than one time.  But what does Harry do?  He saves Malfoy’s life.  And that’s just the beginning of integrity in these stories.  I won’t list the rest of them. 

Now, onto another point.  I have no problem with people who have been convicted to not watch Harry Potter in their homes.  But I do have a problem with them telling me that the Lord told them to tell me to stop or judging me because of it.  I’m not really a pro-public school parent, but I’m not telling other parents that the Lord told me to tell them to pull their kids out of school because Christians have no business putting their kids in public school.  Same concept.  And here’s some scripture that I feel backs me up on this whole subject:  Romans 14:1-4
"Accept the one whose faith is weak, without quarreling over disputable matters.  One person’s faith allows them to eat anything, but another, whose faith is weak, eats only vegetables.  The one who eats everything must not treat with contempt the one who does not, and the one who does not eat everything must not judge the one who does, for God has accepted them.  Who are you to judge someone else’s servant?  To their own master, servants stand or fall.  And they will stand, for the Lord is able to make them stand."

With that being said, if you’re going to be one of those anti-Harry Potter people on the grounds of “not watching or reading anything containing witchcraft,” then please remove the following from your homes, bookshelves, and even church libraries:  The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings, The Chronicles of Narnia, Star Wars, The Wizard of Oz, every Disney Princess movie and other Disney movies, and so many more. 

You might be wondering why I decided to write this blog.  Well, I’m a writer of fantasy and have many Christian friends who also write fantasy.  We all believe that through literature, the gospel can be portrayed, much like it was in The Lord of the Rings.  Am I called to write for the Christian or the person who is not a Christian, but likes fantasy?  I say the latter, although both is my hope.

 
While we're on the subject of Christian writers who write fantasy, I'd like to share some of them with you in case you're like me, and you love fantasy.  All of these writers touch on controversial topics that some Christians bash them for.  They continue to do what they believe God has called them to do.  Please support them by giving their writing a chance.  These indies write about some or all of the following: magic, mummies, fairies, wizards, witches, werewolves, vampires, zombies, and even real-life hermaphrodites.  


William Woodall
Mary C. Findley
Brad Francis
Cynthia Hickey

Lianne Simon
A.E. Rought
Adam Bolander
Kristin King

As always, thanks for joining me in the shade!  Cynthia P. Willow
6 Comments
William Woodall link
12/16/2012 06:57:16 am

All these people have written Christian fantasy books which are beautiful and entertaining, and all of them are so richly different. Christian fantasy is the most amazing genre of books there is, in my humble opinion. I'm thrilled that it keeps growing and maturing and becoming more varied every day!

Reply
Brad Francis link
12/16/2012 12:13:37 pm

Real-life hermaphrodites. . .the most mystical creature of them all! =) Thanks, Cynthia, for taking the time to discuss this. You're right that there's a great deal of inconsistency in the way many approach fantasy elements in different medium, and I'm glad you're now relying on your Bible and your brain as your guide, instead of just gobbling up what others feed you. God bless!

Reply
Adam Bolander
12/16/2012 11:40:45 pm

Great article, Cindee! I agree with everything you said (funny, since we've discussed all of this already, lol). You make a lot of great points. I think I'd also like to bring up the fact that while Harry Potter has pretty much been thrown under the Christian Bus, hardly anybody takes the time to realize that there is another series of books (and one movie) that was written with the goal to be pretty much an Anti-Narnia. They're called the "His Dark Materials" series, but most people will more quickly recognize the title of the first book, "The Golden Compass." These were written by an devout atheist to, as he was quoted saying, "Kill God in the hearts of young children." In those books, God is depicted as a horrible tyrant, and the heroes of the book are on a quest to kill him- a noble quest, the book leads you to believe. It always blows my mind that books like this can pass almost completely below the church's radar, while other stories, like Harry Potter, which have innumerable good qualities, are blasted to pieces by people who don't know the first thing about them.

Reply
Cynthia P. Willow
12/16/2012 11:51:28 pm

Thanks, William, Brad, and Adam for the comments. Adam, I remember when "The Golden Compass" came out. I'm not sure where you're from, but in the town I was in, it went through the same bashing as Harry Potter. Of course, I was listening to a Christian radio station almost every day at the time. And once again, I checked it out for myself. We actually own the movie, but we really don't watch it b/c it wasn't all that good to me. However, I didn't see any of those things in it that you mentioned. I guess it's really disguised. I have heard that the first movie was tamed down quite a bit in order to make it seem innocent and gain fans. Have you seen it, or has anyone else seen it? I won't really defend it b/c although I didn't see all the bad things that I warned about, I didn't really see any good things either. The only thing I really enjoyed was Sam Elliot's voice as the polar bear. Thoughts?

Reply
Mary C. Findley link
12/16/2012 11:54:42 pm

I only watched 2 of the movies, and read all of the books except the last one. I consider the Harry Potter philosophy to be a ministry opportunity. Lessons of courage, personal sacrifice, friendship, and the use and abuse of power abound, but i can't say I love the books or series or the message that we don't need anybody except other human-like beings (no God is a message that is SCREAMED out in Harry Potter), but just have to properly tap the power within ourselves.

Reply
Adam Bolander
12/16/2012 11:55:13 pm

honestly, no I haven't read or watched the movie (collapses under the weight of hypocrisy) but I have several friends who have. I actually do know a few Christians who have read it and greatly enjoyed it. It wasn't, they said, until the second and mainly the third book that the author really began to bash on Christianity. One of my closest friends once described the third book as the authors personal vendetta against God and everyone who calls themselves His follower.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Author

    I love to write fiction and fantasy with a twist of faith.  I usually focus on a young adult audience, but have ventured into some mature stories as well.  But, you don't have to be young to enjoy my writing, just young at heart. 

    Archives

    March 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    June 2015
    January 2015
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    March 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012
    November 2012

    Categories

    All
    Audio Books
    Christmas
    C.S. Lewis
    Dragons
    Ebooks
    Fairies
    Fantasy
    Harry Potter
    Hobbit
    Movies
    Narnia
    The Lord Of The Rings
    Tolkien
    Vampires

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.